What to buy: Notebook or Desktop?

In your quest to purchase the best PC for your money, your first decision is whether to buy a Notebook or a Desktop.

The Notebook form factor offers the following advantages over the Desktop:

Mobility - you will not be chained to your desk, if you have a Notebook
Comparative freedom from wires - its mind-boggling just how many wires go into (and come out of) a Desktop PC!
Much lesser space requirement compared to a Desktop
Freedom from Power Supply problems - you need Power to charge a Notebook's batteries alone and when fully charged, you can run it off its batteries for about two hours!
Ability to start up work much quicker than with a Desktop PC, since you do not really need to switch off a Notebook PC each time - merely closing the lid (and letting it hibernate) is sufficient

If you're contemplating buying a PC (or gifting one), any time is the right time!

Vendors are clamoring to get your attention with discounts, freebies and add-ons! So go get tempted!

We help you choose the RIGHT Computer (Branded/ Assembled Desktop/ Notebook) for your specific needs

Check out our PC Buying Section for a simple, tried and trusted PC Purchase model!

Unable to decide whether to purchase an Assembled or a Branded Desktop PC? Check out this link!

The question is not merely whether you want to splurge on a dazzling Notebook: the question also is whether you really need all these features! Maybe, maybe not! If you do not, you ought to seriously consider a Desktop instead, as it has the following advantages over the Notebook PC:

Desktops cost much less than a similarly-configured Notebook. Look at it another way, you get much better specifications and a much faster Desktop, for the same amount of money that you would spend on a Notebook
Desktops are also far easier and cheaper to maintain/ upgrade. Notebook parts cost twice or more than the cost of a similar part for a Desktop. Therefore, 512 MB of RAM for the Notebook could very well cost twice what you would pay, for 512 MB RAM for the Desktop!
You can even fix common Desktop problems yourself. With a Notebook, you have no choice but to lug it to the nearest Service Center and wait patiently until it is repaired - a process that could take weeks, depending on which part of the world you are in! Even if you have on-site warranty for your Notebook, you still need to wait for the technician's arrival and diagnosis...

There are a few other important factors that you must consider, before buying a PC - Branded/ Assembled Desktop or Notebook. Here is a listing, with a brief explanation of each factor:

Subjective Factors Table:
Factor	Description
Initial Budget	Everyone has a budget in mind, while purchasing anything important. In the case of PCs too, prices vary a great deal from place to place and time to time. Again, Notebooks cost significantly more than Desktops with the same specifications
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)	Initial price is one thing, the cost of maintaining a PC would vary a lot too, depending on whether it is a Notebook or a Desktop. Notebooks not only cost more initially, they cost more to maintain as well. You need to change its Battery once every 2 years or so and repairs will cost you more too - all of it adding to a higher total cost of ownership (TCO)
Future-proof	You may be planning to upgrade your PC (add more Memory, Hard Disk space, etc.) from time to time. On the other hand, you may be planning to use the same PC for a few years, without adding new components or enhancing existing components to it too. If you plan to upgrade (even if you don't, it makes good sense to look closely at upgradation options!), since Notebook upgrades cost significantly more than Desktop upgrades
Mobility	You could be planning to use your PC extensively, while you are on the move. On the other hand, you may be planning to use it mostly at the same spot in your home or office. In the first instance, you ought to consider Notebook more closely, while a Desktop may be better value-for-money if you do not plan to work while on the move
Power Supply	You may have clean power supply at your primary place of work, be it your home or your office. On the other hand, your primary place of work may have frequent power problems (Spikes, Surges, Black-outs, Brown-outs, Low Voltage, etc.). If you have clean power supply, you could be looking closely at a Desktop, while an irregular power supply would mean you look closely at a Notebook
Space	You might have a whole room at your disposal for your new PC. On the other hand, you might have to squeeze out space out of a crowded desk, for your new PC. If space is no constraint, a Desktop may be the better choice, while a Notebook may be the better choice if space is a constraint
Service Standards	You will definitely require professional service for your PC. Therefore, it is a good investment to ascertain the vendor/ supplier's service standards. Reputed suppliers are usually eager to provide you with a list of their customers, so that you may talk to some of them yourself. Pick up a few of these customers at random and talk to them - it would definitely go a long way towards understanding a suppliers service standards
Specs-Usage	The specifications (specs) of models vary - sometimes quite significantly. What really matters though is what you plan to use your PC for. You may be planning to use your PC primarily for simple stuff like e-Mail, Browsing, writing letters, keeping track of your personal finances, etc. On the other hand, you may be planning to use the PC for complex work like Video Editing, Engineering Design and Drawing, specialized scientific applications, etc. You could also be planning to play high-end Computer Games in your spare time. Your PC purchase decision will therefore depend heavily on what you plan to use it for
Warranty Terms	Check out the warranty terms offered by the suppliers - you never know, you may have to avail it… Notebooks come with 1 year as well as 3 years warranties, usually global. You need to clearly ascertain this, though. Desktops too come with 1 or 3 year warranties, usually local, since a desktop is not carried around on inter-continental flights.
	Notebook warranties do not cover the Batteries. Nor do they cover electric or physical damages. This is true of Desktops too
	Again, you have the option of availing on-site warranty or off-site warranty. If you go in for on-site warranty, the vendor's technicians will visit you, in case you face PC Problems. However if you have availed of off-site warranty, you will need to take the crashed PC to the vendor's service center

PCs: Hardware, Software and Computer Services. And, People who use PCs

People seeking reliable advice for PC Purchases

People seeking advice for extracting maximum utility from their PCs

People looking for reviews of and purchase links for top-notch Security Products (AntiViruses, AntiSpyware, etc.)

Small/ Home Offices with Networked PCs, seeking maximum RoI from their IT Investments/ advice on expanding IT Infrastructure

People and Corporations planning to set up professional, contemporary, optimized, aesthetic websites

Worldwide IT Vendors looking for authentic, professional and inexpensive Market Research on global IT Markets

Software Developers wanting to Document/ create quality User Manuals for their Products/ Services

Obviously, all these factors may not be important to you. For example, you may not be concerned about Space requirements at all. Your neighbor, who is planning to gift a PC, may not be concerned about Specs-Usage, Warranty Terms or Service Standards as much as you would be, had you been choosing a PC for your own use. Again, while the power supply at your place of work may be excellent, it may not be so at someone else's place of work. Such factors are subjective: what is most important to you could be least important to someone else, and vice-versa!

To add to the confusion, the specifications of many of these factors are subjective (non-quantifiable) too. Perhaps the only two truly quantifiable factors in the list above are Budget (in terms of the price) and Warranty Terms (in terms of number of years of warranty). You simply cannot quantify Service Standards or Specs-Usage!

With that being the case, the Brown-Gibson offers a simple, intuitive yet accurate method for arriving at a decision. It is based on paired comparisons, with a higher preference (between any 2 factors or 2 models) being given a 1 and a lower preference being given a 0. And if a pair of factors are equally important, both of them are assigned a preference of 1.

From the Preference Table that is thus formed, the Decision Weights and the Subjective Factor Weights are determined and in the final step, the Total Weight of each short-listed model of PC (Notebook or Desktop or a mixture of both) are arrived at. The higher the total weight, the more suitable the model is, to your specific set of preferences!

To assist you with the Brown-Gibson model, we have solved a case from scratch. It explains how to use the Brown-Gibson Model, in a step-by-step manner. You are welcome to download the example Excel file.

Click here to download free, the Brown-Gibson Example File.

Start by reading through the Tab "Legend", then go on to the other Tabs, understanding the working of the Model.

The final steps of the case are briefly reproduced below: we consider 7 Decision Factors and 5 PC models (including 2 Notebooks) in our illustrative example:

Importance of each Subjective Decision Factor, in the Decision Process
Decision Factor	Description of Importance	Decision Weights
Budget	Limited Budget, want for value-for-money. Budget is an extremely important factor (Most Important)	0.273
Future-proof	May want to add a second Hard Disk or more Memory later - not sure at the moment (3rd-most Important)	0.136
Mobility	Most of the times, the PC will be used at home. Occasional mobile computing is likely, though (4th-most Important)	0.091
Power Supply	Erratic power supplies during monsoon, Power consumption and power quality are important considerations (2nd-most Important)	0.182
Space	Ample space is available. Space is least in terms of importance	0.000
Specs-Usage	Quite unlikely that the PC will be used for complex computing, in the next 3 years	0.045
Warranty Terms	Warranty Terms are extremely important in this decision (Most Important)	0.273

Five models of PCs (including 2 Notebooks) have been short-listed. Their specs with respect to each of the 7 Subjective Decision Factors are presented in the Tables below:

Model Weights for each Subjective Factor
1. Budget
Models	Cost after final Negotiations	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	Cost = INR 35,000	3rd lowest price
Model 2	Cost = INR 30,000	2nd lowest price
Model 3	Cost = INR 90,000	Highest price
Model 4	Cost = INR 25,000	Lowest price
Model 5	Cost = INR 65,000	4th lowest price
2. Future-proof
Models	Upgradability of the Models	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	2nd HDD & RAM upgradable	Maximum Future-proof
Model 2	2nd HDD & RAM upgradable	Maximum Future-proof
Model 3	Only RAM upgradable	2nd worst Future-proof
Model 4	No upgradation possible	Least Future-proof
Model 5	HDD & RAM upgradable	3rd worst Future-proof
3. Mobility
Models	Mobility of the Models	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	Desktop Model	Not Mobile
Model 2	Desktop Model	Not Mobile
Model 3	Notebook Model	Mobile (Notebook)
Model 4	Desktop Model	Not Mobile
Model 5	Notebook Model	Mobile (Notebook)
4. Power Supply
Models	Power Supply requirements of the Models	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	PC with 15" CRT Monitor	Max. power required for CRT Monitor
Model 2	PC with 15" LCD Screen	Less power required for LCD Screen
Model 3	Notebook with 12" TFT Screen	Least power required for small TFT screen
Model 4	PC with 15" CRT Monitor	Max. power required for CRT Monitor
Model 5	Notebook with 15" TFT Screen	Less power required for TFT Screen
5. Space
Models	Footprint (Space requirement) of the Models	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	Full Tower Model Desktop	Maximum Space required
Model 2	Baby Tower Model Desktop	3rd most space required
Model 3	Small-sized Notebook	Least space required
Model 4	Baby Tower Model Desktop	3rd most space required
Model 5	Standard Notebook	2nd most space required
6. Specifications
Models	Technical Specifications of the Models	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	P4, 120 GB/ 1 GB RAM, 256 MB External Graphics Card	2nd best specs
Model 2	P4, 80 GB/ 512 MB RAM	3rd best specs
Model 3	Core Duo, 80 GB/ 1 GB RAM, Graphics Card	Best specs
Model 4	Celeron 40 GB/ 256 MB RAM	Bare-bones specs (Worst specs)
Model 5	Core Duo, 60 GB/ 1 GB RAM, No Graphics Card	3rd best specs
7. Warranty Terms
Models	Warranty Terms of the Models	Specification Descriptions
Model 1	Parts replacement only	3rd-best Warranty Terms
Model 2	Parts replacement only	3rd-best Warranty Terms
Model 3	3 years global warranty	Best Warranty Terms
Model 4	No warranty	Worst Warranty Terms
Model 5	1 year global warranty	2nd-best Warranty Terms

For the above Decision Criteria and Model Specifications, application of the Brown-Gibson Model gives the following Decision - the link above contains the complete method of solving the problem.

Final Rankings
Total Weight of each Model and Your Final Decision
Model	Total Weight	Final Ranking of Models
Model 1	0.194	Fourth-best Model
Model 2	0.233	Best Model
Model 3	0.227	Second-best Model
Model 4	0.137	Fifth-best Model
Model 5	0.209	Third-best Model
Total of Total Weights	1.000

As per the Brown-Gibson Model therefore, the best PC and therefore the best decision is Model 2, which has the following specs:

Cost: INR 30,000/-
P4, 80 GB Hard Disk and 512 MB RAM
2nd HDD & RAM upgradable
Desktop PC with 15" LCD Screen
Baby Tower Model
Parts replacement only

This is very closely followed by Model 3, which has the following specs:

Cost: INR 90,000/-
Core Duo, 80 GB/ 1 GB RAM, Graphics Card
Only RAM upgradable
Notebook PC with 12" TFT Screen
Small-size Notebook
Parts replacement only

Once you are familiar with the working of this model, you may create your own Spreadsheet, adding/ deleting other factors that have not been considered here - the solution process is the same, whatever be the number of decision factors or short-listed models. In fact, you may use the Brown-Gibson model for any purchase decision - automobiles, TVs, Home Theatre Systems, whatever! All that you need are;

A good grasp of how the Brown-Gibson Model works
Ability to convert your physical (subjective) factors and specifications into Brown-Gibson Preferences. In other words, you need to be able to fill in the Brown-Gibson Tables correctly

Now that you have downloaded the example Brown-Gibson Model and understood how to fill it in with your preferences and thereafter, to interpret the final solution, you are ready to apply it to your situation.

The working Brown-Gibson Decision Model Spreadsheet is priced at US$ 4.95. Click on the secure PayPal link below and download your password-protected, working Brown-Gibson Decision Model Spreadsheet! We will supply you the password, so that you are able to put it to use rightaway! All you need to do is put in your decision and subjective weights and let the spreadsheet give you your answer! Note, that this is a protected spreadsheet - the cells for inputting your priorities alone can be written on/ deleted! When prompted to, save the Microsoft Excel file "Brown-Gibson Decision Model Example.xls" to your Hard Disk.

Once you click Save and save the Spreadsheet to your PC, you need to fill in the Worksheet titled "Data Sheet" alone. Within Data Sheet too, you need to fill in the white-colored cells within the eight tables alone - since the remaining cells either have formulae or text descriptions in them, you should not overwrite them. In case you make a mistake filling the cells, you may change your preferences anytime by overwriting the concerned cell
To ensure that you do not inadvertently overwrite formulae or text descriptions, cells that need no inputs from your side have been protected
The Second Worksheet, titled "Decision Sheet", is where you will find the answer to your PC (Desktop or Notebook) purchase decision, once you complete filling in Data Sheet. An incomplete Data Sheet will NOT give you a complete or comprehensive answer!
The remaining two Worksheets titled "Weights Sheet" and "Legend" are not required for your calculations. The Weights Sheet is present for my benefit - all calculations are based on the values in the Weights Sheet, with the Weights Sheet filling in automatically, when you populate the Data Sheet. The Legend sheet is for your benefit - it explains each of the Decision Factors as well as how to fill in the Data Sheet, in detail.

NOTE: Do not delete any of the four Worksheets in the Excel file! If you do, you will have to download a fresh copy, to apply the Brown-Gibson model all over again to your decision-making exercise!

On the other hand, if you would like us to do the analysis for you, our charges are US$ 9.95. To complete the analysis on your behalf, we require the following information from you:

The models that you have short-listed and their specs.
All your Decision Weights parameters, so that the decision is tailor-made for your needs. For example, is Budget more important to you than the Warranty terms, and so on.

What we deliver are;

A clear ranking from Rank 1 to Rank N, for all your short-listed models.
The completed Brown Gibson Decision Model Spreadsheet containing the Ranking of your choices, within 3 days of receipt of all information and payment from your side.

Click the correct option in the secure PayPal Dropdown Menu below!

Click here to download the password-protected, working Brown Gibson Decision Model Spreadsheet

The Brown-Gibson Decision Model is a tried and tested model for decision-making. A number of universities and organizations have used it successfully in various situations and conditions. Besides this, a number of papers/ research projects have also applied it successfully. For further reading, check out the following select links:

The Rutgers Scholar

Title page for ETD

CAT.INIST

The Source Selection Evaluation Decision Support System

Purchase Modern Production/ Operations Management by Elwood S. Buffa (original publishers Wiley). It probably has the best coverage of the Brown-Gibson Model amongst text books.

728x90